Our Blog

Rear End Crash Denied Summary Judgment

June 11, 2013

In Borowski v. Ptak, (4th Dept. June 2013), a 3-2 decision, the Fourth Department upheld the lower Court’s denial of a summary judgement motion for defendant.

This rear-end crash was a little different than most cases. In this case the Plaintiff was the party that rear-ended the defendant. Defendant then moved for summary judgment. The Court however found that the plaintiff came forth with a non-negligent reason for the crash, i.e. defendant’s sudden stop. Even though defendant claims she was stopped for thirty seconds or more, the court held that this created an issue of fact for the jury.

The court held “Here, plaintiff testified at his deposition that he was unable to discern whether defendant’s vehicle was stopped because defendant’s brake lights were not activated. Plaintiff, however, also submitted the deposition testimony of McCulloch and defendant in which they both described traffic conditions on the date of the accident as “congested” and “stop and go.” Additionally, plaintiff submitted evidence that defendant stopped suddenly. Indeed, plaintiff testified at his
deposition that defendant apologized to plaintiff for the accident, explaining that McCulloch had stopped suddenly and that defendant “couldn’t help it.” That evidence, when viewed in the light most favorable to the nonmoving party (see Nichols v Xerox Corp., 72 AD3d 1501, 1502), establishes a sufficient nonnegligent explanation for the collision.”

Request Your Free Consultation

Get the answers and support you need. Our friendly and experienced Buffalo personal injury lawyers will take the time to understand your case, explain your options, and guide you every step of the way.

Five gold stars representing a 5-star client rating for a Buffalo, NY law firm

Our Practice Areas

Read More Articles

Silver sedan with a crushed front end stopped on a highway after a crash, with a school bus and semi truck behind the barrier

How Does a Car Accident Claim Work in New York?

New York’s car accident claims process can be confusing because it involves both no-fault insurance and, in some cases, a separate claim against the person who caused the crash. If you have been injured in a car accident in Buffalo or elsewhere in the state, understanding how these

Read Blog